Week 1 Discussion 1
Discuss your position regarding access to and coverage for health care. Are we obligated to
provide access to and coverage for health care for all Americans as an entitlement (a
right)? Or should health care be considered a commodity that is subject to the influences
of economic, social, and market demand (supply and demand)? Be sure to include the
rationale for your position in your discussion.
Week 1 Discussion 2
What are the barriers to nurses’ participation in the development of health care policy at
the state or national level or in an organization in the United States? Why do you think these
are barriers? Support your opinion with a rationale or example.
Instructions to both discussions:
– Picture below is the book for this class, and preferred source to use, outside source
is OK.
– -At least 250 words per discuss
Week 1 Discussion 1: Access to and Coverage for Health Care
The question of whether access to and coverage for healthcare should be considered a right or a commodity is a complex and contentious issue. My position strongly leans towards viewing healthcare as a fundamental right rather than a commodity.
First and foremost, I believe in the moral imperative of ensuring access to healthcare for all individuals. The right to health is recognized internationally as a fundamental human right. Denying individuals access to healthcare based on economic status or social factors not only perpetuates inequality but also undermines the basic principles of justice and human dignity.
Furthermore, from a pragmatic standpoint, providing universal access to healthcare has numerous benefits for society as a whole. By ensuring that everyone has access to preventive care, chronic disease management, and timely treatment, we can improve overall public health outcomes, reduce healthcare costs in the long term, and enhance productivity. Healthy individuals are better able to contribute to their communities and economies.
While acknowledging the role of market forces in shaping healthcare delivery, I believe that healthcare should not be treated purely as a commodity subject solely to the forces of supply and demand. Healthcare is unique in that it involves matters of life and death, and allowing market forces to dictate access to essential services can result in significant disparities and injustices.
In conclusion, I firmly advocate for the recognition of healthcare as a fundamental right rather than a commodity. Not only is it a matter of moral imperative, but it also aligns with pragmatic considerations for improving public health and societal well-being.
Week 1 Discussion 2: Barriers to Nurses’ Participation in Health Care Policy Development
Nurses play a crucial role in healthcare delivery, yet there are several barriers to their meaningful participation in health policy development at the state, national, or organizational levels in the United States.
One significant barrier is the hierarchical structure within healthcare organizations and policymaking bodies. Nurses, despite their frontline experience and expertise, often face marginalization within these hierarchical structures. Decisions regarding healthcare policy are frequently made by individuals with medical or administrative backgrounds, sidelining the valuable perspectives that nurses can offer.
Another barrier is the lack of time and resources available to nurses for engaging in policy advocacy. Nurses are typically overburdened with clinical responsibilities, leaving little time for involvement in policy-related activities. Additionally, many nurses lack training and education in health policy and advocacy, further limiting their ability to participate effectively.
Moreover, there can be institutional barriers within healthcare organizations that hinder nurses’ involvement in policy development. Organizational cultures that do not prioritize or value nurses’ input in decision-making processes can discourage their participation. Additionally, bureaucratic hurdles and administrative barriers may impede nurses’ efforts to engage in policy advocacy.
In conclusion, while nurses possess valuable insights and experiences that can inform health policy development, various barriers hinder their meaningful participation in the process. Addressing these barriers requires efforts to promote a culture of inclusivity within healthcare organizations, provide nurses with the necessary education and resources for policy advocacy, and create pathways for nurses to engage in decision-making processes at all levels of the healthcare system.